Facing Up to Sentimentality

{ via Tiny Buddha }

“Ordinary riches can be stolen, real riches cannot. In your soul are infinitely precious things that cannot be taken from you.”

– Oscar Wilde

I've been delivered some pretty firm e-smackdowns when writing about sentimental items before. I've upset a few people and lost a few readers. And I'm OK with that because not everyone has the same ideas about sentiment, emotion and stuff. And sometimes people aren't ready to think too deeply on their attachment to particular sentimental items. Both of those is perfectly OK.

I used to struggle to let go of artwork, birthday cards, ribbons, concert tickets, travel documents and gifts because I thought the memory of the person, the time, the place or the celebration was in that item. I worried that if I let it go, the memory would disappear and I would somehow care less.

But I've discovered (and continue to discover) that the memory is in us. Old photos or a memento from a trip can help us recall the memory, but the memory is still there. The question I ask of myself is,

“If I was living life more mindfully (ie. paying attention) would I need to have my memory jogged?”

I think the answer is probably yes, because life is busy and time passes quickly. But surely, if we paid more attention to the things happening in front of us, the people we love, the memories we're making, wouldn't our reliance on sentimental stuff lessen?

I'm not here to tell you to give away your grandmother's pearls or your child's first lock of hair. But I do have three questions for you to ask yourself when faced with the task of decluttering sentimental items.

Asking these questions means you are doing what's right for you and your life, rather than following a set of rules. It also means tackling the sentimental stuff takes longer and is more emotionally draining than decluttering, say, the kitchen drawers or wardrobes. So be patient with yourself. Take time. Don’t let go of certain things if you are really having trouble with it.

You know the best answers for your own life. Sometimes that means going with your gut. Sometimes it means being brave.

Before You Begin

Choose a very small area to start. Perhaps you could work through:

  • one storage box of keepsakes
  • a shelf of knick-knacks
  • a cupboard of old toys or clothes from your grown-up children

Everyone has (or used to have) a place in their home like this. Somewhere that tugs at the heart strings when you think of it.

So pick your spot, grab a garbage bag, a recycle bag and a donate box. And simply start.

Three Questions to Ask Yourself

For each item you pick up, ask yourself these questions:

1. Does this item mean something to me?

Often we keep things because we think we “should”. Or because it is representative of good times, fun holidays, our now-grown children, or people we love. But does the actual item, the thing you’re holding in your hand mean something to you?

If not (and you may be surprised by how many of these things do not mean anything on close inspection) then the decision to remove it from your home should be simple. Decide whether to donate it or throw it away.


2. What emotion does this item bring out?

If you've decided the item does mean something to you, then ask yourself what emotion you feel upon holding it.

Study that emotion for a moment.

What is it? Why do you feel it?

Would you still feel that emotion without the physical item? (If yes, then your decision has again been made. Decide to donate or throw away.)

Do you have multiple items that rouse the same emotion? What if you kept one or two that are truly meaningful, instead of keeping everything as a blanket reaction?

If there is no strong emotional attachment, then again, you can more easily decide to remove it from your home.


3. Would I display the item in my home?

We all keep things that we wouldn’t display in our home. And it’s not my intention to have you remove everything that you wouldn’t hang on the wall. But asking yourself this question forces you again to really examine why you’re holding on to the item and what the item itself means to you.

If you wouldn’t display it, then really examine your reasons for keeping it. (Remember, there is no right or wrong here. But the intention is to pare down and simplify these sentimental things.)


Once you’ve asked yourself these questions and decided whether to keep the item, donate it or throw it away – you can let go and be proud.

Let go of the guilt of removing it from your home.

Let go of the weight of the thing you are keeping.

Be proud that you are surrounding yourself and your loved ones with things that are truly meaningful.


If You’re Really Struggling…

If you’re really having difficulties letting go, you can box up the firm maybes, write the date on the box and 6 months later, if you haven’t missed or needed anything in the box, donate it, unopened.

(Avoid this if possible though – you are more likely to hold on to things unnecessarily if you know there is a second-chance rule.)


There is no easy way to declutter and simplify sentimental items, but these questions should help as you move through your storage. Also know that it does get easier. As you begin to feel lighter and happier in your newly simplified home, it will not be so difficult to let go of things.

And if you’re struggling, please let me know in the comments or via email. It’s hard, and I’ve been there!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Join the Slow Your Home Tribe!
Sign up to get the 7-Day Slow Home BootCamp delivered straight to your inbox as well as the fortnightly newsletter and exclusive Tribe-only updates.

13 Responses to Facing Up to Sentimentality

  1. Kathy in Chicago says:

    When I was reading thru the questions, I kept thinking of 1 thing in particular that is very precious to me: my children’s baby teeth. When I got to the last question “Would I display the item in my home” all I thought of how creepy that would be to have my children’s teeth on display in the living room. Thanks for making me laugh!

    • Kelsey says:

      LOL That is quite a funny notion!

      Although, if you are considering whether or not to hold onto them, may I suggest burying them in a potted plant or the garden? They will break down eventually, and the calcium will nourish the soil, and you’ll have a beautiful houseplant you can use to continue the memory in a way that is more appropriate to display :-)

      Also gets around the uncomfortable moment of throwing them in the garbage….instead its more of a transformative moment for the little baby teeth.

    • Brooke says:

      OK, that literally made me laugh out loud!! But, if you’re unsure what to do with them, I really do love Kelsey’s suggestion.

  2. Belinda says:

    Thank you for this great post, Brooke! I don’t comment often but I do read every post you write :-) I have always been very sentimental, even as a child, so this is a huge issue for me in de-cluttering/simplfying.

    Your maybe box idea really worked for me not long ago. We bought some lovely new plates to replace our old mismatched ones, but in the process of discarding the old ones I couldn’t let go of three of them from my mum. They were from the first dinner set my parents bought when they got married (now divorced). I remember thinking “If I throw these away then there will be nothing left of their marriage.”

    I decided to put them in a box for 6 months instead of leaving them in the kitchen. And I didn’t think of them that whole time! I only remembered them when I found the box by accident. After having some space I’m now ready to let go of them. I realise this was about me not wanting to let go of the past. It’s amazing the emotions that can be attached to three old, chipped plates! :-)

    • Brooke says:

      Thanks, Belinda! So glad you said hello. And it’s great to hear about what’s working for you. I know so many people (myself included) struggle with the emotions of things and IN things. Putting time and space between us and the thing/s is a good place to start.

  3. Marnie says:

    Oh, you nailed this one on the head for me! Yikes! I faced this last week with two beautiful pieces are art work I purchased on a family vacation in Costa Rica. Truth is…although lovely paintings, they fit NO WHERE in our home space at all. It was so hard…but…I donated them and accepted that some other space would relish and love the paintings…

  4. Christina says:

    In the last 3 months I have gotten rid of tons of sentimental things, because after reading another blog on minimalism, I realized I don’t want my children to have to go thru this stuff when I’m gone. Of course, I kept some, diplomas, a few cards, but a lot has gone. I’ve given away original art work that I’ve just stored ,because I haven’t used it in 10 years. On and on.
    Thanks for a great article on keeping and letting go.

  5. Rebecca says:

    Thanks for the suggestion on whether I would display some of my “sentimental” items. For me the answer right now is no just because I am lacking shelf space and have a 4 year old. Plus this helps me to let go of even more things and be even lighter. Thanks.

  6. Sarah says:

    So true. Nice work taking us all by the hand and walking us through it.

  7. Heather says:

    So glad I found this discussion. I just decided to google ‘hard time getting rid of sentimental things’ because we are moving and I have a house of child hood memories for my daughters who are teenagers now. So good to see that there are other people who are sentimental like this. Appreciating all the ideas. My friend told me that she took pictures of her children’s art work so she would not have to store it. I do like the 6 month box idea. Silly me, I just packed a box of sentimental plush toys. I think that the girls may want to see them later and make the choice to get rid of them. I think it is too that I loved their childhood so much and it’s a way to hold onto that time and remember those feelings. It’s going to be a process for me to keep letting go of this stuff. Thanks for the great ideas !!

  8. May I just say what a comfort to uncover an individual who really knows what they’re talking about on the internet.
    You certainly realize how to bring an issue to light and make it important.
    More and more people ought to check this out and understand this side of your story.
    I was surprised you’re not more popular given that you surely
    possess the gift.

  9. All your emotions’laughter, sorrow, cheerfulness and Wholesale Snapback Hatsworry’are expressed on your face.
    You might have to find a few people who will be interested in buying from these wholesalers if you want to meet their
    minimum order quantity, but the effort will be worth it in the end.

    You may have seen many people pulling of the snapbacks together with their outfits.

  10. Hi there I’m not sure if it is me or maybe your blog site but it is loading incredibly slow
    for me, it took me like a moment in order to load up still gmail operates totally .
    Nevertheless, I appreciate you for putting up an incredibly fantastic article.
    Everybody who discovered this page must have observed this
    content totally helpful. I personally must state that you
    actually have done wonderful work with this plus expect to discover further great
    things from you. To get additional knowledge through content that you write-up, I
    have book-marked the site.

Leave a reply